How to Find Good Tenants: A Landlord's Complete Guide

Finding a good tenant is the single highest-leverage decision you make as a landlord. A reliable tenant who pays on time, takes care of the property, and renews their lease is worth thousands of dollars more than a problematic tenant who pays late, causes damage, and requires an eviction.

The good news: quality tenants are not rare. They're looking for quality landlords. Make your rental process professional and you attract professional tenants.

---

Prepare the Property First

Before advertising, your unit should be:

Clean and freshly painted. First impressions determine whether a quality tenant applies or keeps looking. A dated, dingy unit signals a landlord who doesn't maintain their property — exactly the landlords quality tenants avoid.

Professional photographs. Smartphone photography is acceptable if done carefully — good lighting, wide angles, every room photographed. Poor photos dramatically reduce the quality of applicants. Consider hiring a real estate photographer for $100-150 if you're in a competitive market.

All repairs completed. Do not show a unit with broken fixtures, dripping faucets, or damaged flooring. Fix everything before the first showing. Quality tenants notice deferred maintenance and factor it into their decision.

Priced correctly. Pull comparables for your area. Price at or slightly below market for fastest lease-up. Overpriced units attract fewer applicants and sit vacant longer.

---

Where to Advertise

Online Listing Platforms

Zillow Rental Manager — the largest rental listing platform in the US. High traffic, free basic listings. Most quality tenants start their search here.

Apartments.com — strong in urban and suburban markets. Good for 2+ unit properties.

Facebook Marketplace — particularly effective in smaller markets like West Tennessee where local Facebook groups have high engagement. Free to list.

Craigslist — still active in many markets, especially for lower price points. Free. Be aware of scammers — verify all applicants carefully.

Nextdoor — hyperlocal platform. Excellent for reaching established residents in your neighborhood who may know someone looking. Free.

Local Channels

Word of mouth — tell everyone you know. Your best tenant referral may come from a current tenant, a neighbor, or a colleague. A tenant who comes referred by someone you trust is more likely to be someone you can trust.

Local Facebook groups — "West Tennessee rentals," "Union City housing," neighborhood groups. Post directly to where your target tenant is already looking.

Local bulletin boards — laundromats, grocery stores, community centers, churches. Old-fashioned but still effective in smaller markets.

Real estate agents — some tenants use agents to find rentals, especially relocating professionals. Offering a finder's fee (typically one month's rent) to agents can bring you high-quality referred applicants.

Employer housing boards — if there are major employers in your area (hospital, factory, university) they often have housing resources for new employees. Contact HR departments.

What Your Listing Should Include

• Complete address and unit number
• Number of bedrooms and bathrooms
• Square footage
• Monthly rent and security deposit amount
• Lease term (12 months, month-to-month)
• Utilities included (if any)
• Pet policy
• Parking situation
• Laundry — in-unit, on-site, or none
• Available date
• Your minimum screening criteria (optional but filters out unqualified applicants)
• Professional photos — all rooms
• Contact information and how to schedule a showing

---

Pre-Screening Before Showings

Showing your unit takes time. Showing it to unqualified applicants wastes that time. A brief pre-screening call before every showing filters out poor fits early.

Pre-screening questions:

• When are you looking to move in? (Matches your available date?)
• How many people will be living in the unit?
• Do you have pets?
• What is your current monthly income? (Quick 3x rent check)
• Have you ever been evicted?
• Have you ever broken a lease?

You don't need to be invasive — just verify the basics before investing time in a showing. Anyone who refuses to answer basic pre-screening questions tells you something important.

---

Conducting Showings

Show the unit in person. Virtual showings became common during the pandemic but in-person showings remain the gold standard. You want to meet the applicant, and they want to see the property.

Be on time. Showing up late to your own showing signals disorganization. Quality tenants notice.

Present the unit professionally. Lights on, temperature comfortable, fresh smell. If the unit has unique features — good light, large closets, quiet street — mention them.

Observe the applicant. How do they treat the space? Do they touch things carelessly? Ask good questions? Seem genuinely interested in the property?

Note questions they ask. A tenant asking about parking, storage, and neighbors is engaged and thinking about living there. A tenant who asks nothing may be shopping casually or just checking boxes.

Have applications ready. If the applicant is interested have a rental application ready to hand them — or direct them to your online application. Strike while the interest is warm.

---

What to Look for in Applicants

Strong Signals

Long employment history with same employer. Stability in employment predicts stability in tenancy.

Rental history with same landlord for 2+ years. Long tenancies mean they know how to be a good tenant.

Income well above 3x the rent. Not just meeting the minimum — comfortable margin means financial stress is less likely.

Positive previous landlord references. Especially from the landlord before the current one — harder to coach.

Clean credit with no collections or evictions. Not perfect credit — collections and late payments matter but especially eviction judgments.

Organized and prepared. Shows up on time, brings ID, has questions ready, submits application promptly. These are behavioral signals about how they'll handle tenancy.

Warning Signs

Urgency to move in immediately. Sometimes legitimate — job relocation, lease ending. Sometimes they're being evicted or have another problem. Verify the reason.

Inconsistent or vague employment history. "I do freelance work" requires income verification more carefully.

Reluctance to authorize background or credit check. A quality tenant with nothing to hide doesn't hesitate.

Stories about why previous landlords were terrible. Some landlords are genuinely bad. But a pattern of difficult landlords suggests the pattern may be the tenant.

Offers to pay several months upfront. This can mean they know they won't pass screening and are trying to compensate. Run the full screening regardless.

Pressure to decide quickly. Quality tenants understand the screening process takes time. Applicants who pressure you to skip steps are usually the applicants who need the screening most.

---

The Application Process

Once you have interested applicants:

1. Collect completed written applications from every adult who will live in the unit
2. Collect the application fee to cover screening costs
3. Run the full screening — credit, criminal, eviction, income verification
4. Call previous landlords — at least the last two
5. Evaluate against your written criteria — consistently for every applicant
6. Make your decision and notify all applicants

Take applications simultaneously if you have multiple interested parties. Evaluate everyone against your criteria and choose the most qualified — not simply the first to apply.

---

Keeping Good Tenants

Finding a good tenant is only half the work. Keeping them is the other half.

Respond to maintenance requests promptly. Nothing drives good tenants to move faster than feeling ignored.

Respect their privacy. Give proper notice before entry. Don't drop by unannounced.

Be reasonable. When small issues come up — a late payment during a genuine hardship, a lease question — handle them with good judgment, not rigid rule enforcement.

Acknowledge long-term tenants. A tenant who has been with you for three years is more valuable than a new tenant at a slightly higher rate. Treat them accordingly.

---

Finding Tenants with TameRent

TameRent's tenant screening module handles the entire process — FCRA-compliant consent capture, screening report ordering, AI-generated summaries from Marlo, and automated adverse action notices if you decline.