How to Screen a Tenant: A Landlord's Step-by-Step Guide

Finding a good tenant is the single most important thing you do as a landlord. A bad tenant costs you months of lost rent, thousands in damages, and weeks of stress. A thorough screening process protects your investment — and done correctly, it also protects you legally.

The FCRA — What Every Landlord Must Know

The Fair Credit Reporting Act governs how landlords use consumer reports in rental decisions. Before you request any screening report you must:

1. Disclose in writing that you may obtain a consumer report
2. Get written authorization from the applicant before ordering any report
3. Send an adverse action notice if you deny the application based on the report

Skipping any of these steps exposes you to FCRA liability — including statutory damages of $100–$1,000 per violation plus attorney fees.

---

What to Screen For

1. Credit History

A credit report shows you an applicant's payment history, outstanding debts, and any collections or judgments. What to look for:

Green flags:

• Credit score above 620 (650+ preferred)
• No recent eviction judgments
• No utility collections (signals payment problems)
• Stable payment history over 2+ years

Red flags:

• Multiple recent late payments
• Active collections accounts
• Recent bankruptcy (within 2 years)
• Eviction judgment in the last 3 years

Set a minimum credit score threshold and apply it consistently to every applicant. Inconsistent standards create fair housing exposure.

2. Criminal Background

Criminal screening requires particular care. Several states and cities have "Fair Chance" housing laws that restrict when and how you can use criminal history in rental decisions.

Tennessee currently has no statewide Fair Chance housing law, but federal fair housing guidance from HUD cautions against blanket criminal history bans — particularly for arrests without convictions or offenses unrelated to the tenancy.

Best practice: Evaluate criminal history on a case-by-case basis, considering:

• Nature and severity of the offense
• Time elapsed since the offense
• Evidence of rehabilitation
• Relevance to the rental situation

Never consider: Arrests without convictions, expunged records, or juvenile records.

3. Eviction History

An eviction judgment is the clearest signal of tenancy risk. A tenant who has been legally evicted — as opposed to one who moved out voluntarily — demonstrates a pattern that is difficult to overlook.

Look for eviction filings (not just judgments) — many landlords dismiss cases after the tenant pays, but the filing itself tells you something.

4. Income and Employment Verification

The standard qualification is gross monthly income of at least 3x the monthly rent. At $800/month rent you're looking for $2,400/month gross income.

Verify income with:

• Two recent pay stubs
• Bank statements (3 months)
• Offer letter for new employment
• Tax returns for self-employed applicants

For Section 8/voucher applicants: You cannot apply the same income ratio — the voucher covers a portion of rent. Calculate based on the tenant's portion only.

5. Rental History

Call previous landlords — not just the current one. A current landlord who wants to get rid of a problem tenant may give a glowing reference. The landlord before the current one is more reliable.

Ask:

• Did they pay rent on time?
• Did they give proper notice before moving out?
• Did they leave the property in good condition?
• Would you rent to them again?

That last question is the most important. A hesitant "yes" tells you as much as a direct "no."

---

The Screening Process — Step by Step

Step 1 — Application

Collect a written rental application from every adult who will live in the unit. The application should capture:

• Full legal name, date of birth, Social Security number
• Current and previous addresses (3 years)
• Current employer, income, and length of employment
• References (personal and landlord)
• Pet information
• Signature authorizing screening

Charge an application fee ($35–75) to cover screening costs and filter out non-serious applicants.

Step 2 — FCRA Disclosure and Authorization

Before ordering any report, provide a written FCRA disclosure and get signed authorization. This must be a standalone document — not buried in the rental application.

Step 3 — Run the Screening Reports

Order your reports through a FCRA-compliant screening provider. A full bundle typically includes:

• Credit report with score
• Criminal background check
• Eviction history
• Income verification (optional)

Step 4 — Verify Income and Employment

Call the employer directly using a number you find independently — not one provided by the applicant. Verify employment status, start date, and income.

Step 5 — Call Previous Landlords

Speak to at least the two most recent landlords. Document what they tell you.

Step 6 — Make Your Decision

Apply your criteria consistently:

• Does the applicant meet your minimum credit score?
• Does their income meet the 3x requirement?
• Is their rental history satisfactory?
• Does their background check raise concerns?

Document your decision and the reasons for it in writing.

Step 7 — Adverse Action Notice (If Denying)

If you deny the application based in whole or in part on a consumer report, you must send an adverse action notice within a reasonable time. The notice must include:

• The name, address, and phone number of the consumer reporting agency
• A statement that the CRA did not make the decision
• The applicant's right to obtain a free copy of the report within 60 days
• The applicant's right to dispute the accuracy of the report

---

Setting Consistent Screening Criteria

Write your screening criteria down before you advertise the property. Apply the same criteria to every applicant. This protects you from fair housing claims and creates a defensible record.

Sample minimum criteria:

• Credit score: 620 or higher
• Income: 3x monthly rent (gross)
• Rental history: No eviction judgments in last 3 years
• Criminal: Case-by-case evaluation per HUD guidance

Post your screening criteria in your listing or provide them upon request. Transparency builds trust with quality applicants.

---

Common Screening Mistakes

Screening after showing the property — screen before you invest time in showings. A brief pre-screening phone call saves everyone time.

Accepting the first applicant — take applications simultaneously if you receive multiple. Choose the most qualified, not just the first.

Inconsistent standards — applying stricter criteria to some applicants than others is a fair housing violation waiting to happen.

Ignoring red flags because the applicant seems nice — a friendly demeanor does not pay rent. Use objective criteria.

Not documenting your decision — if a denied applicant files a complaint, your written documentation is your defense.

---

Tenant Screening Made Simple

TameRent handles the entire screening workflow — FCRA-compliant consent capture, report ordering, AI-generated screening summaries, and automated adverse action notices — all in one place.